Nestled at the foot of a Victorian-Gothic confection designed by Frederick Clarke Withers and enclosed by an ornate wrought iron fence dedicated by Brooke Astor, the Jefferson Market Garden appears to have enjoyed a long and privileged life. The garden is an island of leafy peace on a tranquil triangular block amid the swarming traffic of Greenwich and 6th Avenues in Manhattan, on the border of Greenwich Village and the West Village. At its heart a green pool of lawn is surrounded by fastidiously groomed mixed borders and cooling trees. Paths are punctuated by benches where locals and tourists mingle quietly or read a book. Catbirds call from the shrubbery and in spring the branches hop with migrating warblers.
The garden shares the block with the architectural confection—now the Jefferson Market Library, a branch of the New York Public Library. It was originally a courthouse, designed by Frederick Withers, Calvert Vaux’s business partner. (Subsequent reviews describe its style variously as Venetian Gothic, American Gothic and Victorian Gothic—take your educated pick.) When the courthouse was completed in 1877 the New York Times described the ornate building as “a jewel in a swine’s snout,” referencing the rough, down-at-heel surroundings of the time. Then, the courthouse’s neighbor was not a horticultural sanctuary, but a prison.
The current vibe, in a part of the city where townhouses sell regularly for over $10 million dollars, is a little different.
The lot where the garden began to grow in 1975 has a complex history: First the eponymous food market of 1833, it was later the site of two prisons, the second an 11-story Art Deco fortress that was the Women’s House of Detention, which opened in 1931 and whose demolition was complete in 1974. A year later a fledgling garden emerged in the derelict space, brought to life by community activism and designed by landscape architect Pamela Berdan (who helped transform several other local green spaces). In 2025, the garden celebrated its half-centenary.
Since 1999 the Jefferson Market Garden’s design and care have been led by Susan Sipos and her landscaping firm Gardens of Distinction, assisted by a dedicated team of volunteers who meet to work every Monday, when the space is closed to the public. Major tree work is taken care of by professional arborists: The blizzard of February 2026 saw the toppling of a mature pine, which destroyed its witch-hazel companions as it fell; and mature crabapples were removed last year after succumbing to fire blight and to old age. Funding for work at the garden is overseen by a volunteer-board and is raised from grants and donations.
If there is a floral star in New York’s public gardens in late spring, it is ornamental Alliums. Irresistibly photogenic, structural and strong, their broad starbursts are especially effective poised above a sea of ostrich ferns in the Jefferson Market Garden.
As spring progresses the rose garden becomes a magnet for visitors entranced to find such scented and well-tended abundance just feet away from five lanes of traffic. Mid to late May sees the roses at peak bloom.
As the season turns, summer annuals and scented Brugmansia shrubs transform the the gardenscape. Where tulips bloomed, statuesque dahlias rise higher than the fence. Fall brings welcome warm color to the trees and shrubs. In winter, a pretty greenhouse on site remains tended by gardeners while the gates close and the garden rests.
The garden entrance is on Greenwich Avenue, between West 10th Street and Christopher Street. The garden is open daily from April 1 to October 31 from 10 AM to 6 PM.
Jefferson Market Garden is one of 26 in my new book, Secret Gardens of New York—Green Hideaways in the Heart of the City (Quadrille Books, October 2026), available now to pre-order.
See also:
- Snowscape Visit: The Max Family Garden in Brooklyn
- Ask the Expert: Photographer and ‘New York Green’Author Ngoc Minh Ngo on her Favorite NYC Green Spaces
- Design Wild: Turning the Streets of New York into a Garden
Have a Question or Comment About This Post?
Join the conversation